

Angle
Managing Law Firm Client Risk Part One: Engagement Letter Governance
- 1 min
Key Takeaway: Emerging trends in client outside counsel guidelines (OCGs) and law firm engagement terms increase risk and operational complexity. Clients are imposing more prescriptive information governance, AI, and billing requirements, while firms seek to limit liability. Firms reduce exposure by centralizing client requirements, assigning clear ownership for review and approval, standardizing workflows, and tracking obligations.
This two-part series will examine both sides of the compliance challenge, beginning with outbound engagement letters. Firms often use these agreements to limit risk and preserve flexibility for future representations. However, recent judicial decisions demonstrate the limits of blanket protections. Inconsistent execution and tracking create institutional blind spots, turning intended safeguards into liabilities. As discussed in part two, the emergence of AI also presents highly novel issues that command attention.
Attention on Arbitration Clause Constriction
Firms often use mandatory arbitration clauses in their engagement letters to mitigate exposure. Although they may draft these clauses broadly to cover any dispute related to the representation, courts may limit their enforceability based on the clause wording, placement, and execution.
In a recent dispute involving an Am Law 50 firm and a client alleging extensive misconduct in a bankruptcy matter, a federal judge held that the firm’s arbitration clause did not apply. Although the clause covered: “[a]ny controversy, claim, or dispute arising out of or relating to our agreement,” its placement in a section addressing fee disputes limited its scope (See: In re Eletson Holdings Inc., Adv. Proc. No. 25-01120 (JPM), (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. Aug. 3, 2026)).
The firm’s argument was further weakened by separate written-consent attachments requiring client signatures. The parties disputed whether those attachments had been properly executed.
Lesson: Revisit Your Firm’s Engagement Letter Template, Execution, and Management Practices
Arbitration clauses reduce exposure to public litigation, unpredictable jury outcomes, and reputational harm. The Eletson decision does not invalidate broad arbitration clauses, but it illustrates the risks created by poor drafting and inconsistently executed engagement letters.
An adverse ruling can quickly turn an assumed protection into an inventory problem. Because engagement letters may vary by partner preference, client negotiation, and jurisdiction, firms should govern their content, delivery, and execution rather than treating them as a formality.
Firms should also audit their existing engagement letters, identify compliance gaps, and strengthen governance and workflow practices.
Assessing Advance Waiver Applicability
Advance conflict waivers are another tool firms use to preserve business flexibility by obtaining prospective consent to represent adverse parties in future, unrelated matters.
Like arbitration clauses, advance waivers have faced increased judicial and ethical scrutiny. Courts and ethics authorities have limited open-ended waivers, including those negotiated with sophisticated corporate clients, when the terms do not support informed consent.
Without disclosure of foreseeable adverse matters, identifiable counterparties, or clear subject-matter boundaries, broad prospective waivers may expose firms to disqualification, fee forfeiture, and malpractice claims (See: Sheppard, Mullin, Richter & Hampton, LLP v. J-M Manufacturing Co., Inc., 6 Cal. 5th 59 (2018); ABA Model Rule 1.7, cmt. (22)).
Lesson: Advance Waivers Require Defined Scope, Not Blanket Consent
Courts assess informed consent based on what the client reasonably understood when the waiver was executed. Boilerplate becomes outdated as corporate families, practice areas, and disputes change. A promise to provide future notice may not satisfy ethical requirements, and unilateral notice may not cure concurrent adversity. Even sophisticated clients are entitled to clearly stated terms and full disclosure. Without a pre-defined scope for permissible adverse matters such as routine employment claims or IP prosecution, a court may invalidate the waiver and order fee disgorgement.
Firms should define defensible parameters at the outset and track them in a structured repository. They should also obtain renewed consent when relationships exceed the original scope.
Reckoning With Retention Rules and Cloud Storage Costs
Engagement letters may also create risk and expense when they do not clearly define document-retention and data disposition obligations. Gaps persist even among firms with mature information governance programs.
Missing engagement letters and omitted destruction timelines increase legal and cybersecurity risk while creating operational burdens and driving higher data storage and supplier costs.
Cloud document management systems have made costs more visible. Under on-premises models, firms could expand server capacity through incremental capital investment. Cloud suppliers typically charge monthly based on consumption. Without an authorized disposition deadline or client approval, firms may retain material indefinitely.
Organizations with multiyear agreements and limited included storage may therefore face significant unplanned expenses. In some environments, the resulting exposure can reach six figures.
Lesson: Rising Costs Strengthen the Case for Compliance Investment
Information governance teams have long highlighted retention risks. Rising operational costs add urgency to the business case for action. Appropriate action includes analyzing retention expenses, identifying gaps in engagement-letter practices and showing management the cost of omitted disposition clauses.
Additionally, firms should also define disposition timelines at matter inception, integrate retention policies into operational workflows, and conduct file closure and data disposition when representations end and applicable timelines expire.
Modernizing the Engagement Lifecycle: Audit, Automate, and Account
Part two of this series will further explore response strategies and how client outside counsel guidelines (OCGs) complicate engagement governance. In the meantime, there are several key points and guidelines of which firms ought to take note:
Strengthening engagement letter governance enables law firms to better protect themselves and their clients. The best way to start is to take a fresh, focused look at current data and practices. Begin with a thorough inventory of historical agreements to identify unexecuted letters, non-standard provisions, and matters opened without properly executed engagement letters. If your firm is not already using software to centrally store, manage, and report on client commitments defined by engagement letters and OCGs, this is an excellent opportunity to adopt modern infrastructure.
In parallel, assess existing retention cost exposure. Firms can quickly identify potential liability by analyzing cloud storage consumed by inactive matters that have exceeded standard disposition thresholds. Once they have a clear view of the current landscape, they can then identify where policies and processes fall short or areas for improvement.
Firms can dramatically accelerate remediation programs by subsequently partnering with specialist advisors who understand the ethical contours of legal risk, the technical elements of workflow and data management, and the economics of cloud cost management.
Learn more about how Epiq New Business Intake Consulting and Document Management enable firms to audit existing agreements, streamline business acceptance workflows, and improve engagement letter management.

Mark Denner, Senior Director, Epiq Advisory for Law Firms
Mark equips law firms and legal departments to align document management, enterprise search, and risk management with information governance objectives. He has hands-on implementation expertise with iManage and NetDocuments and is certified across Intapp’s full suite of risk and data management technologies.

Mike Guernon, Director, Risk Advisory
Mike Guernon works with Am Law firms to enhance risk management practices, address evolving professional responsibility requirements, and better integrate compliance technology into the fabric of firm operations. His three decades of experience center on Intapp implementations and enterprise risk design across conflicts, intake, KYC and AML, OCGs, and compliance.
The contents of this article are intended to convey general information only and not to provide legal advice or opinions.